‘Round the Town
Knead to Know – Your Mini-Guide to the Area’s Best Bakeries
Rising to the occasion, these local bakeries are proof that life is sweeter with freshly baked treats. From artisanal breads to decadent pastries and cakes, each spot brings something special to the table.
Le Petit Gâteau
525 North End Drive Carmel, Indiana 46032 lpgbakery.com Where French finesse meets artistic vision, Le Petit Gâteau is more than just a bakery—it's a canvas for Chef Chris Holland's culinary creativity. A fusion of his fine arts and pastry training shines through in every creation, from seasonal fruit-studded pastries to innovative Sunday specials like Oreo croissants. Their award-winning custom cakes and desserts have earned a reputation as edible masterpieces worth celebrating. 
Pots & Pans Pie Co.
4915 North College Avenue Indianapolis, Indiana 46205 potsandpansindy.com From the south edge of SoBro, Pots & Pans Pie Co. believes perfection comes wrapped in pastry. What began as a farmers market favorite has evolved into a carry-out sensation, where seasonal sweet and savory pot pies showcase the versatility of this timeless comfort food. Here, every handcrafted slice upholds their motto: everyone deserves a well-made pie. 
Rise’n Roll
9705 Fishers District Drive, Suite 760 Fishers, Indiana 46037 risenroll.com From humble Amish roots to beloved Indiana institution, Rise'n Roll Bakery stays true to its foundation of from-scratch baking and real ingredients. Their legendary cinnamon caramel donuts emerge fresh daily alongside a tempting array of handcrafted pastries and breads—each bite showcasing the simple perfection of traditional recipes and quality ingredients. 
Aspasia Bake Shop
3091 US-421 N Zionsville, Indiana 46077 aspasiabakeshop.com At Aspasia Coffee and Bake Shop, Eva Tomlinson proves that gluten-free can be gloriously delicious. In this dedicated gluten-free haven, family recipes are thoughtfully reimagined—from salted caramel brownies to celebration-worthy custom cakes. Every scratch-made creation, served alongside local coffee in their bright, welcoming space, makes dietary restrictions feel anything but limiting. 
My Sugar Pie
40 E. Pine Street Zionsville, Indiana 46077 mysugarpie.com What began in her mother's kitchen has blossomed into Zionsville's sweetest success story. At My Sugar Pie, Kelly Maucere carries forward cherished family recipes, including her nationally acclaimed Sugar Cream Pie and "Mom's Original" Dutch Apple. Each scratch-made creation—still often crafted alongside her mother—proves that the best family traditions are baked with love. |
The Cake Bake Shop
Carmel City Center 800 S. Rangeline Road, Suite 260 Carmel, Indiana 46203 thecakebakeshop.com At Carmel City Center, The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers dazzles with crystal chandeliers and French elegance, creating an enchanted setting for indulgent moments. Behind grand French doors, their signature towering layer cakes take center stage alongside artisanal pies, delicate macarons, and exquisite pastries. Here, every dessert is served with a sparkling side of sophistication. 
Titus Bakery
17471 Wheeler Road Suite 110 Westfield, IN 46074 titusbakery.com From their award-winning maple bacon long johns to specialty creations that dominate local donut festivals, Titus Bakery has spent three generations perfecting the art of the perfect donut. This Lebanon landmark, now with a Westfield location, stays true to time-tested recipes while innovating new favorites—proving that some traditions only get sweeter with time. 
Taylor’s Bakery
8395 E. 116th Street Fishers, Indiana 46038 talyorsbakery.bakesmart.com Four generations of family expertise are folded into every creation at Taylor's Bakery, where time-tested recipes and made-from-scratch tradition remain the secret ingredients. While their cases tempt with daily delights, it's their custom cakes that truly showcase the family's artistry—turning life's sweetest celebrations into edible masterpieces that taste as good as they look. 
Leviathan Bakehouse
1101 N. College Avenue Indianapolis, Indiana 46202 leviathanbakehouse.com In Indianapolis' Chatham Arch neighborhood, Leviathan Bakehouse artfully bridges old-world craftsmanship with contemporary flair. Here, traditional techniques meet modern imagination, creating a gathering space where quality reigns supreme—from the meticulously crafted pastries (we recommend the Gorgeous George Éclair), bakes and breads to the warm sense of community that fills this urban sanctuary. 
Debbie’s Daughters Bakery & Cafe
1236 Conner Street Suite 100 Noblesville, IN 46060 debbiesdaughters.com In downtown Noblesville's historic district, Debbie's Daughters embraces the rhythm of the seasons with their small-batch, from-scratch philosophy. Each morning brings fresh delights to their bakery counter—from warm cinnamon rolls to seasonal scones—while their café menu spotlights the best of each season and a weekly pre-order system helps with thoughtful meal planning. |