INDY UNWRAPPED
2024 Holiday Gift Guide
Unwrap the magic of the holidays with our exclusive guide to one-of-a-kind finds at beloved local shops. From handcrafted jewelry and cozy winter apparel to gourmet chocolates and custom decor, these 16 boutiques offer gifts filled with personality, quality and heart. Every purchase supports Indy’s talented makers, passionate retailers and dedicated artisans, making your holiday shopping both memorable and meaningful. As you check off your list, explore the best of Indy’s independent stores and enjoy discovering unique treasures you won’t find anywhere else. Support small businesses, give back to the community, and make this holiday season truly special. Happy holidays, and happy local shopping!
For Sparkling Surprises…
Petite G Jewelers At Petite G Jewelers, Dana Friedman and her expert team curate a dazzling collection of boutique designer jewelry you won’t find anywhere else. Their stunning selection of Helena Rose rings captures the essence of timeless design and personal expression. "We believe that jewelry, like personality, should flow effortlessly through the rhythm of your day, becoming a seamless part of your life,” says Dana. “Each piece embodies the spirit of an heirloom—a handcrafted celebration of self-expression that resonates across generations, gaining depth and significance as it is passed down." Visit Petite G Jewelers at 5609 N. Illinois Street in Indianapolis. Find them online at petiteg.com and follow @petitegjewelers on Instagram. 
For Distinctive Designs…
Charles Mayer & Co. Since 1840, Charles Mayer & Co. has been Indianapolis's legendary retailer of distinctive gifts. The expert team delights in helping select the perfect holiday gift from their curated collection of fine crystal, silver, and luxury accessories and always offers elegant wrapping. This season, owner Claudia Ryan is pleased to offer the latest arrivals from Michael Aram, including his Orchid and Wildflowers Collections, capturing ethereal grace in metal. His Anabel Aram jewelry line, inspired by his daughter, is also popular, featuring hand-cast, gold-dipped pieces that reflect joyful sophistication. Find Charles Mayer & Co. at 5629 N. Illinois Street in Indianapolis. Shop online at shop.charlesmayer.com and follow @charlesmayerco on Instagram. 
For Gourmet Gifting…
DeBrand Fine Chocolates Delight your chocolate connoisseurs with world-class confections crafted right here in Indiana at DeBrand Fine Chocolates. Their artisanal creations, made with only the finest ingredients and meticulous attention to detail, range from oversized truffles to specialty confections. The Classic Collection, featuring luscious caramels and pure fruit creams, bursts with intense flavors and is beautifully packaged to make gift-giving effortlessly impressive. Indianapolis partner Lori Sonner says, "Whether you're shopping for a loved one or the whole office staff, DeBrand Fine Chocolates has the perfect gift for everyone on your list." Visit DeBrand Fine Chocolates at 8685 River Crossing Boulevard in Indianapolis or call Lori at 317-669-0955 to place an order.
For Party Glam…
Civvie Boutique This holiday season, elevate your celebration style at Civvies. Their dedicated stylists pride themselves on helping each customer find pieces that make them feel their absolute best. The must-have Miley Sequin Boyfriend Tee by Bishop + Young transitions effortlessly from office party to evening out, says manager Robyn Cefali adding, “We have a wide variety of dressy to casual holiday options from sequins, faux leather and velvet to cozy holiday sweaters.” Check out their newly launched holiday capsule collection for the perfect combination for every festivity. Visit Civvies in SoBro at the 54th and Monon Shops. Find shopcivvies.com online and follow @shop_civvies_indy on Instagram for their latest styles. 
For Local Nostalgia…
The Shop Celebrate cherished memories with The Shop at Carmel City Center, where local nostalgia comes to life through hand-printed apparel. Since 2011, their in-house designers have transformed beloved Indiana moments into wearable art, from vintage sports teams to iconic venues of yesteryear, while also offering the latest licensed college and pro team gear. These conversation-starting pieces make perfect holiday gifts, sparking joy and connection through shared hometown pride. Each high-quality design tells a story of our community's rich history, making them more than just apparel—they're personal expressions available for the whole family. Visit The Shop in Carmel City Center. Shop online at theshopindy.com and follow @theshopindy on Instagram for the latest hometown styles. 
For Festive Finds...
Linden Tree Step into Linden Tree, where holiday magic fills every corner. From festive fashion and cozy winter accessories to enchanting ornaments, colorful candles, and seasonal décor, their thoughtfully selected collection makes holiday shopping effortless. New holiday arrivals are added throughout the season, and the friendly staff is always willing to wrap up your newfound treasures. Don't miss their new Watercolor Workbooks featuring beginner-friendly illustrations on premium paper, perfect for creating peaceful holiday moments alone or with family. Visit Linden Tree Gifts locations in Carmel City Center and downtown Noblesville. For more information, visit lindentreegifts.com and follow @lindentree_gifts on Instagram for news and events. 
For Modern Men…
Heritage Clothier and Home Heritage Clothier and Home brings refined men's style and décor to Broad Ripple. Their American-made Hometown Collection was born out of a deep love for Indiana's heritage, from its bustling cityscapes to the tranquil beauty of its countryside. "We wanted to create something that not only celebrates Indiana's history but also the contemporary culture and character that makes our home state so special," says the design team. The collection features stylish and versatile pieces, including cozy sweaters, quarter zips, scarves, and home décor. Visit Heritage Clothier & Home at 1134 East 54th Street in Indianapolis. Shop online at heritageclothierandhome.com and follow @heritageclothierindy on Instagram. 
For Playful Presents…
Kits & Kaboodle At Kits & Kaboodle Classic Toys in Carmel City Center, a delightful exhibition of fun and developmental toys amuse infants, children, and adults alike. The knowledgeable staff helps select perfect gifts from premium brands like Steiff, HABA, and LEGO. This year, owner Teneen Dobbs is loving the Thames & Kosmos Gecko Run, a TIME Magazine Best Invention winner. "It has resonated with so many people because it's a fun twist on the classic marble run," she says. Visit Kits & Kaboodle at Carmel City Center. Shop online at kitsandkaboodletoys.com and follow @kitsandkaboodle on Instagram for gift ideas and events, including a Meet & Greet with the ‘Mean One’ on December 7th from 1:30pm - 3.30pm. |
For Local Treasures…
Mercantile 37 Step into Mercantile 37, a charming maker's market where father-son duo JR and Nick Roudebush showcase over 100 Indiana artisans in a uniquely curated celebration of local style and community spirit. With an array of quality vintage and locally-made products, including pottery, woodwork, apothecary, small-batch pantry items and more. Build-your-own gift boxes are perfect for holiday gifting, says Nick, adding, "Folks love to fill them with a mix of vintage and handmade goods." Kick off your holiday shopping and celebrate Small Business Saturday on November 30th at Mercantile 37, at 25625 State Road 37 North in Noblesville. Find more information online at mercantile37.com and follow @mercantile37 on Instagram. 
For Little Looks...
Lunch Money Boutique Create magical holiday memories at Lunch Money Boutique, where Butler-Tarkington's upscale children's shop offers festive pieces for picture-perfect moments. Their collection of holiday pajamas from Petit Lem, Magnetic Me, and Sweet Bamboo ensures sweet mornings and moments to treasure for years to come. For gifts that spark wonder, owner Shallan Hazlewood recommends Copernicus Toys' engaging STEM kits, blending education with entertainment with everything from root beer brewing to bubblegum making. Treat the children in your life to gifts they’ll love at Lunch Money Boutique at 5617 N. Illinois Street in Indianapolis. Visit lunchmoneyboutique.com online and follow @lunchmoneyboutique on Instagram. 
For Sophisticated Styles…
The Secret Ingredient For over 40 years, The Secret Ingredient has been an Indianapolis fashion destination. This season, owner Pamela Ellis presents an elegant collection of cold-weather essentials, from luxurious cashmere capes to cozy vests in rich winter textures. Complete your look with carefully selected accessories—plush scarves, cozy gloves, designer hats, and gleaming jewelry. Their expert stylists help you discover exclusive designer collections perfect for every occasion. Join them on November 21st for a special shopping event benefiting the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra Association North Group. Visit The Secret Ingredient in the Shoppes at 56th and Illinois in Indianapolis. Shop online at thesecretingredient.us and follow @secretingredientstore on Instagram. 
For Accessory Afficianados…
Purse Strings Find the perfect accessory at Purse Strings, Hamilton County's family-owned fashion destination. As Indiana's largest retailer of enewton jewelry, Purse Strings offers an extensive selection of stackable bracelets, allowing you to create personalized gifts, says owner Paul Braun. Each gold-filled piece is designed for everyday luxury, meant to be worn while swimming, sleeping, and everything in between. Choose from classic pearls, sparkling gems, or meaningful charm designs. Complete your gift with local Ambre Blends perfumes, or explore their exclusive collection of designer handbags. Visit Purse Strings at Clay Terrace and Hamilton Town Center, as well as Hammitt by Purse Strings at The Fashion Mall. Shop online at purse-strings.shop and follow @purse_strings on Instagram. 
For Intimate Undergarments…
Barbara’s New Beginnings Celebrate the season of self-care at Barbara's New Beginnings, where expert fitters help you discover the perfect intimate gifts for every body. The locally owned boutique, recognized among the nation's top five shops for bra fitting, offers a stunning selection of lingerie, including the must-see Freya Sydnie Bodysuit. This standout piece showcases sheer floral lace with elegant gold details, a ladder front with scalloped edges, and a playful keyhole back. Their thoughtfully curated collection ensures everyone finds their perfect fit in a comfortable, professional setting. Plus, gift certificates are available—perfect for sharing the gift of confidence and comfort with loved ones. Visit Barbara’s New Beginnings at 8635 River Crossing Blvd in Indianapolis. Shop online at barbarasnewbeginnings.com and follow @barbarasnewbeginnings on Instagram. 
For Seasonal Scents…
Bath Junkie Create custom holiday bliss at Bath Junkie in Carmel City Center, where every product is personalized to your perfect scent. Winter wellness favorites include invigorating peppermint shower steamers and essential oil roll-ons, while their signature Spa Day blend of eucalyptus, peppermint, and green tea captures the season's refreshing spirit. For the perfect gift of relaxation, pair their calming lavender sleep mist with a luxurious satin pillowcase. Host a unique holiday event or office party where friends and colleagues can blend their own bath and body products. Visit Bath Junkie in Carmel City Center. For more information, find them online at bathjunkiecarmel.com and follow @bathjunkiecarmel. 
For Hand Painted Heirlooms…
Out of the Blue Polish Pottery At Out of the Blue Polish Pottery & Gifts in Carmel City Center, owner Ruthanne Burgard displays an exquisite collection of hand-painted Polish stoneware perfect for holiday hosting and gifting. Each durable, microwave and oven-safe piece brings artisanal charm to everyday moments, from ornate pie plates to elegant tea sets. "Polish pottery is a way to bring beauty and joy to everyday life," says Ruthanne. Start someone special on their own collection with a unique, functional piece they'll treasure for years to come. Visit Out of the Blue Polish Pottery & Gifts in Carmel City. Shop online at outofthebluepottery.com and follow @polishpotterycarmel on Instagram. 
For Forward-Thinking Fashion…
8FIFTEEN At 8FIFTEEN, owner Elizabeth Lechleiter curates an exclusive collection of designer brands you won't find anywhere else in Indianapolis. This season, discover perfect gift pairings like the must-have metallic silver Beth sneakers by Isabel Marant and the coordinating Betrice leather mittens from Soia & Kyo. From luxe loungewear to statement accessories, the Broad Ripple boutique's skilled stylists delight in helping you select the perfect presents, complete with complimentary gift wrapping. Gentlemen, let Elizabeth and her team help you find the perfect gift at their holiday shopping event November 21st. Interested in a styling appointment? Email claire@8fifteen.com. Visit 8FIFTEEN at 815 E. 65th Street in Broad Ripple and online at 8fifteen.com and by following @indy8fifteen on Instagram. |
